Skip to main content Skip to footer

Supreme court hearing over ATMs in supermarkets - to be heard this week

09 03 20 ATM

Rating experts concerned case could flood the already struggling appeals system and lead to stores ripping out their ATM machines


This week (on March 11th 2020), the Supreme Court will hear the appeal from the VOA, the government’s Valuation Office Agency against its defeat last year in the Court of Appeal concerning the long running dispute with major supermarkets* concerning business rates and ATM machines. According to rating experts at Colliers International, the global real estate advisers, if the hearing goes against the supermarkets, it could lead to stores ripping out their ATM machines, denying many in the local community free access to cash.

In November 2018, the Court of Appeal ruled that ATMs located both inside and outside of stores should NOT be assessed for additional business rates on top of the normal store rates costs, retailers are already facing. This decision overturned the ruling of the Upper Tribunal in January 2017 that made a distinction between ATMs inside a building and outside, and which had said that the sites of ATMs located within premises should not be assessed for business rates, but those ATM sites outside a shop or store should.

Although the Court of Appeal refused the VOA permission to appeal against its decision, in May 2019, the Supreme Court over ruled and allowed the VOA, this right of appeal, a decision branded as a costly “nightmare” by Colliers at the time.

Colliers estimated around £500 million is at stake. Each ATM site attracts an average rates liability of around £4000.  If the Supreme Court upholds the Court of Appeal’s decision, the refunds due to the supermarkets would be in the region of £496 million. The Court of Appeal had also ruled that the VOA must lift the stay on all of the appeals that have snarled up the system for the duration of the case.

If the Supreme Court goes against the supermarkets and supports the VOA, Colliers believe the move will accelerate the closure of ATMs in stores across the country, as supermarkets rip them out of their stores to save on rates bills. Since the UK has lost thousands of ATMs since 2016, exacerbated by the closure of banks, such a decision will only accelerate this decline, bringing even further difficulties for those members of society that rely on them for free access for cash. 

According to John Webber, Head of Business Rates at Colliers International, “We will monitor the forthcoming hearing with interest. Should the case go against the supermarkets it could snatch away from hard pressed retailers the much - needed refunds, they have been waiting for in this period of economic uncertainty. And even if the supermarkets are successful, they will have seen a two-year delay in receiving any refunds, which has not been helpful in the current economic climate. For the VOA a decision against them will not only be costly, but will also result in a flood of appeals that will over burden the already struggling CCA appeals system.”

Webber continued, “Whoever succeeds in the Supreme Court and whatever decision the Law Lords arrive at, common sense and a pragmatic approach needs to be taken- which in the world of business rates seems to be in short supply.

This case should not be a further reason for retail appeals to be delayed, particularly in the current climate with the headwinds all businesses are facing.”

*Sainsburys Supermarket Ltd, Sainsbury’s Bank Plc, Cardtronics Europe Limited, Tesco Stores Ltd, Co-Operative Group Limited v Chris Sykes and Others (Valuation Officers)


Related Experts

John Webber

Head of Rating

Rating

Birmingham

I have over 30 years’ experience in the rating industry and lead a 90 plus rating team at Colliers International.  When I took over responsibility for the team in 2005, it consisted of only a dozen people and has now grown into one of the leading rating advisory teams in the country.  I am a member of Colliers International Management Executive as well as sitting on the company’s promotion panel. 

I am regularly called upon by the national media to give my views on a range of business rates issues and I am vocal commentator on the 2017 Revaluation.

I started my career in the Valuation Office Agency in Kidderminster.  I joined Gerald Eve in 2000 where I spent 10 years before moving to Gooch Webster (now Colliers International). I sit on the National Retail Panel of Rating Surveyors Association which provides guidance on how the RSA town committees work with the VOA and valuation matters.  John sits on the RICS Rating Diploma Committee having passed the prestigious qualification in 2014.

Philip Harrison and I founded 'Accurates' in 2007, the Collier's Compliance and Audit team, which although forms an integral part of the Rating Team is now a leading brand in its own right.

View expert

Hannah Zitren

Associate Director

Marketing & Communications

Manchester

I am responsible for media relations and generating coverage in top tier broadcast and print media. I work across a range of Colliers’ UK & Pan-EMEA business lines advising on their strategic and tactical PR needs.

My role includes:

·         Developing and executing PR plans for the various business lines to help promote their key messages across all aspects of the media - print, broadcast and social.

·          Media evaluation and reporting objectives, targets and successes across the business.

·         Reputation management and crisis management.

·         Media training.

·         Media engagement: setting up meetings with top tier media and various internal spokespeople to continuously expand and build a presence with property and vertical media network.

·         Consistently delivering service excellence, meeting with business heads of a regular basis and trying to influence the research as much as possible to ensure our content has a strong enough news hook.

·         Key campaigns that I work on include MIPIM; MAPIC; REVO; Midsummer Retail Report; IHIF; Cities of Influence in addition to a host of all alternative property sector research reports.

View expert